Fall in Love Again follows Bennet and Bree as they rediscover each other time and time again in their dreams. Each episode shows them falling in love again, even as the real world pulls them in different directions.

When Jade goes missing, Avery realizes it eerily mirrors a past tragedy involving the death of their friend, Mia. When Avery learns that Mia was murdered, she soon discovers someone is orchestrating events to make them relive that horrific summer.