Lisa Clarkson’s picture-perfect life as a high school football coach’s wife begins to unravel when one of her daughter’s best friends is killed in a hit-and-run after the pep rally to kick off the new season. Lisa is torn between supporting her husband and the school while trying to uncover the truth of the accident which could implicate the school’s principal, the star quarterback, and even her husband.

After leaving her Amish community in her youth, a New York book editor finds herself in desperate need of a new cookbook to save her job. With Christmas on the horizon Sarah heads back to her family farm to reconnect. But with the presence of a handsome local—an outsider, but one that is friendly with the Amish community—he and Sarah sense chemistry and work together to save her family’s Amish bakery (developing an Amish Christmas Cookbook in the process).