The dead body of Darlene Krashoc is found dumped behind a restaurant in Colorado in March 1987, victim of torture and sexual assault.

Aspiring influencer Gabby Petito sets out on a cross-country road trip with her fiancé, but she soon disappears and the ensuing mystery goes viral. New footage of the couple sheds light on their struggles that led to the nightmarish outcome.

When shy guy Brent receives a Heavenly communication that he is to marry the complete stranger he encounters in a restaurant, the challenge to find the courage to ask her out disrupts his peace of mind. When a chance opportunity for a gallant rescue leads to the perfect opportunity. Brent makes it to first base. His chances of getting to second base are crushed when Kaitlyn finds out that Brent has beliefs that her own church and pastor father oppose.