After leaving her Amish community in her youth, a New York book editor finds herself in desperate need of a new cookbook to save her job. With Christmas on the horizon Sarah heads back to her family farm to reconnect. But with the presence of a handsome local—an outsider, but one that is friendly with the Amish community—he and Sarah sense chemistry and work together to save her family’s Amish bakery (developing an Amish Christmas Cookbook in the process).

Molly runs the local mom's group and this year they're entering the prestigious Modern Parenting Group of the Year Contest. When a new to town dad, Ashley, sets up a rival dad's group, their competitive natures cause competition in town.