A young couple on an ill-fated second date find themselves up against the elements and each other when they become stranded on a remote lake island.

Carly, a local college student, becomes involved with Abram, a young Amish man, during his Rumspringa. But Abram refuses to return home and takes Carly captive so they can be together at his own twisted version of an Amish community.

A podcast host returns to her small hometown where a recent death rekindles her interest in a long-unsolved case, throwing her into a dangerous game of cat and mouse as she hunts for the truth.