A handsome young man arrives in an Amish community claiming to be homeless. He's taken in and treated with particular kindness by a widowed mother, but she soon discovers he isn't who he claims to be.

When a rising young musician is found murdered at the estate of country music legend Abilene Tucker, all evidence points to the scandal-plagued diva. But as her estranged daughter Caroline digs for the truth, she uncovers a web of obsession.

A criminology student and true-crime club probe a cold case in rural Georgia, exposing town secrets and a hidden killer. Their investigation puts them in the crosshairs of a predator hunting for new victims.